France’s Cour des Comptes (Court of Auditors), in a 38-page report, Les Soutiens de L’état Ă  la Production D’énergie (State Support for Energy Production) warns that low forward electricity prices could jeopardise EDF’s ability to fund its €84bn ($92bn) EPR2 nuclear programme, potentially requiring the state to defer €65bn in dividends. This comes weeks before the company is expected to make a final investment decision on the project.

The Court warns that wholesale prices below €70/MWh would deepen EDF’s financing gap. While 2027 contracts sit near €120/MWh, 2028–2032 forward contracts fall between €50/MWh and €65.75/MWh. The six planned EPR2 units (at Penly, Gravelines, and Bugey) carry a budget of €72.8bn in 2020 values, or €84bn in 2025 values, with initial operations targeted for 2038.

Despite state-backed loans and a price-capped contract for difference, EDF faces major self-funding hurdles. Under bleak market conditions, the state may need to forfeit roughly €65bn in dividends from 2026 to 2040. Auditors highlighted past examples, such as Flamanville 3, where costs jumped from €3.3bn to €23.7bn as a major red flag.

They note that extending current nuclear lifespans to 60 years offers a cheaper low-carbon alternative at under €51/MWh, contingent on safety clearance and maintenance control. In April, the European Commission launched an in-depth investigation to evaluate France’s proposed EPR2 funding framework against EU state aid rules.

The Cour des Comptes recommended prioritising the lifespan extension of France’s existing nuclear fleet and overhauling how the state structures and caps energy subsidies. Auditors noted that total public energy support reached €13.2bn in 2025, prompting them to propose five structural levers to limit fiscal exposure.

Extending the operating lives of current nuclear reactors to 60 years is the only generation investment in France’s 10-year energy plan (PPE3) virtually guaranteed to be profitable. At a full cost of under €51/MWh, it beats new EPR2 reactors, wind, and solar, provided safety approvals are secured, and maintenance costs stay strictly controlled.

The state must tightly control the rollout trajectory of new power plants to prevent both electricity shortages and wasteful overcapacity. While the PPE3 plan already lets officials scale back renewable energy targets if electricity demand grows slower than forecast, auditors urged the government to also tie these adjustments to real-time data on existing nuclear availability, grid interconnections, and EPR2 construction progress.

The Court criticised France’s current subsidy model for allowing overlapping public support schemes to stack without clear justification. It urged officials to establish strict criteria defining exactly when state aid is necessary.

Auditors warned that poor state visibility into producers’ actual costs and weak competition in tenders lead to overly generous ceiling prices. They recommended building flexibility into long-term support contracts – including the proposed 40-year contract for difference for EPR2 – to claw back or correct excessive returns if they emerge.

To prevent sudden fiscal shocks from low wholesale power prices, the court called for a binding medium- to-long-term budget trajectory for all energy support.